Home » Entertainment » TV » Heartbreaking Days Of Our Lives Fatalities

Heartbreaking Days Of Our Lives Fatalities

Dorathy Gass

January 25, 2018

Days Of Our Lives News Round-Up For The Week (March 7, 2022)

When a soap opera character passes away, a little piece of fans’ heart goes along with them. Viewers become invested in the people they see on their favorite daytime dramas, and Days of Our Lives (DOOL) fans are no exception. Whether it’s because an actor has moved on to bigger or better Hollywood opportunities or it’s to add another layer to a plot twist, no matter what the circumstances are, soap opera demises can be a devastating thing to fans. Below are DOOL’s truly heartbreaking fatalities of all time.

Want soap spoilers delivered to your inbox every week? Sign up for Fame10’s weekly soap opera spoilers newsletter.

12. Arianna Hernandez

Arianna Hernandez was a character who was on DOOL for a short period of time between 2009 to 2010 but made a huge impact in Salem. As a sister to Rafe, Gabi, and Dario, as well as BFF with Melanie Jonas, Ari had tremendous roots in the little town and shared a beautiful love story with Brady Black. While storyline-wise her demise did add a layer to the on-going plot, her passing was still quite underwhelming to many fans.

Days Of Our Lives News Round-Up For The Week (March 21, 2022)

11. Dr. Daniel Jonas

The land of soap operas has changed significantly now that the internet and social media are around. Actors can tweet about the comings and goings of their show and spoilers can sometimes ruin a plot twist for fans. Many DOOL viewers knew that Shawn Christian, the actor who portrayed Daniel Jonas, was leaving the show which meant they also wondered how his exit would play out. It was quite saddening when he was axed. A drunk-driving accident took his life, Brady Black got his heart, and fans said goodbye to Shawn and Daniel knowing it would be hard to ever bring Christian/Jonas back in any capacity.

Days Of Our Lives News Round-Up For The Week (February 21, 2022)

10. Isabella Toscano

Digging into DOOL’s history vault we come across another underwhelming demise in 1992. Isabella Toscano was smart, kind, beautiful and had John Black head-over-heels in love with her. She was also a major DOOL player during the time she appeared on the show from the late 1980s until her passing in ’92. Even though fans knew it was coming since she had been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer, her passing was still considered a major letdown. John and Marlena make an incredible super couple, but if Isabella had lived, they may not have stood a chance.

©Aaron Montgomery/JPI

Recast Report Card: Dan Feuerriegel As DOOL's EJ DiMera

9. EJ DiMera

It was confirmed by Kristen DiMera late in 2017 that EJ was alive and well — and finally, he returned to Salem permanently in 2021. However, when he passed away in 2014, many viewers were quite upset. EJ was one of those characters that oscillated back and forth between scoundrel and hero and shared super-couple status with entertaining better-half Sami Brady. Let’s hope he never leaves again.

Days Of Our Lives Character Returns That Totally Underwhelmed Fans

8. Jack Deveraux

Jack Deveraux returned to DOOL in December 2017 (as a ghost), but the appearance simply made audiences wonder why the character was done away with in the first place. As one of Days‘ most well-liked Salem residents of all time, audiences loved his quirky personality and his romance with Jennifer Horton. He did go out in a heroic fashion, risking his life to save his daughter Abigail, and then returned alive several years later.

New Days of Our Lives Characters Who Failed To Impress Fans

7. Zack Brady

Most likely the last thing to watch as a soap opera fan is when a child passes away. Whether you are a parent or not, watching a younger character perish can bring out a ton of emotions from fans. One very underwhelming (and saddening) demise was when Zack Brady passed away. The child was hit by a car his half-sister Chelsea was driving and never recovered from his injuries. In a Greek-tragedy twist, his liver was given to his little niece Claire to save her life.

Love DOOL? Share all of your DOOL opinions and join the discussion on our DOOL Facebook Page.

Days Of Our Lives Couples Who Should Never Get Back Together

6. Bo Brady

When Bo came back to Salem after a three-year hiatus in 2015, DOOL fans rejoiced everywhere. The Brady prodigal son had finally returned, just in time to save Hope, and the super-couple picked up exactly where they left off in a matter of hours. However, the most underwhelming part of this seemingly happy ending was that there was nothing happy about it. Bo was diagnosed with a brain tumor and days after returning to Salem, the Bradys and other loved ones were saying their final goodbyes to him. As underwhelming as it was to believe the iconic Bo Brady was gone for good, viewers can see him in action again on Beyond Salem in 2022!

Days Of Our Lives: Spoilers For November 2020

5. Marlena Evans

Thankfully, Marlena Evans is alive and well today, but that wasn’t always the case. Digging back into the DOOL history vault comes a disliked demise in 1987 when troublemaker Orpheus kidnapped Marlena in an act of revenge against Roman Brady, her then-love. Roman was able to shoot Orpheus but was unable to rescue Marlena from a plane she was being held captive on. Roman, as well as DOOL viewers, watched in horror as the plane exploded. Her body wasn’t found, but in 1991, she resurfaced and re-entered the land of Salem.

Days Of Our Lives Criminals Ranked

4. Lexie Carver

Lexie Carver was a beloved DOOL character that lived in Salem from 1987 to 2012. She was one that walked the fine line between good and evil, being good for the most part, but at times doing questionable things. Carver was considered a fan-favorite, which is why her demise was especially devastating. In 2012 it was discovered that she had brain tumors and with only weeks to live, family and friends helped Lexie scratch things off her bucket list, including turning Salem’s Town Square into Paris. She passed away peacefully with Abe by her side as DOOL fans everywhere balled their eyes out.

Days Of Our Lives Characters We Wish Never Left

3. Will Horton

Will Horton returned from the afterlife late in 2017, which is a true testimony to what a mistake it was for DOOL writers to do away with him in the first place. He was a victim of the Necktie Serial killer in the fall of 2015, which received much backlash from DOOL fans. That is why it is no surprise that Will returned in 2017. Sure, the storyline that resurrected him was outrageous, but at least Horton is back.

Days Of Our Lives Couples Fans Don't Want To See Get Back Together

2. Steve “Patch” Johnson

When Steve passed away in 1990, many DOOL fans were quite upset. He was a huge fan-favorite, one half of the iconic Stayla super couple with Kayla Brady, and a staple with Days. He was injured in a boat explosion that left him in a critical state. While he did almost recover, bad guy Lawrence Alamain poisoned his IV while he was in a coma at the hospital. Steve’s return was inevitable, as Lawrence mysteriously had his coffin switched before he was buried, but DOOL fans waited well over 15 years to see their beloved Patch return.

Days of Our Lives Characters Who Went From Exciting To Boring

1. Stefano DiMera

Yes, DiMera was a schemer, but one the fans loved to hate. As Salem’s public enemy number one, he made storylines intriguing and had nine lives as it seemed nothing could truly ax Stefano and he would always return from the afterlife. In early 2016, Days fans watched in horror as Hope Brady shot the infamous soap opera bad guy three times in the stomach. It simply felt like the end of an era. However, in true Stefano fashion, he would return about a year later. Sadly, the actor who played DiMera (Joseph Mascolo) passed away in late 2016, meaning that while the character of Stefano still lives on, the brilliant actor that played him remains alive in the form of the soap opera legacy that he created.

Howard Wise/JPI

Dorathy Gass

Dorathy Gass is an avid fan of daytime drama and has been watching Days of Our Lives, General Hospital, and Young and the Restless for over two decades now. As a full-time freelance writer, she gets to combine her love of soap operas and writing through her Fame 10 articles. Also a mother of two busy girls and a mommy blogger, she's been published multiple times over in Huffington Post Parents and Scary Mommy.