10 Wackiest Bachelorette Contestants

  
Slide 1 of 5 | View On One Page

The Bachelor franchise is nothing short of crazy and, on each season of The Bachelorette, we settle in with our pop corn to watch the drama of the men in the house unfold. This list countdowns those extreme Bachelorette contestants that make us squirm with their unpredictable and wacky behavior.

10. Justin Rego

No one can possibly forget the amount of drama that ensued after Ali Fedotowsky received a phone call from a girl claiming to be the girlfriend of the wrestler on the show. As it turned out, Justin “R-Rated” Rego had a girlfriend back in Toronto and was just trying to gain some fame. His girlfriend, Jessica Spillas, had actually tried to reach out to Reality Steve for some advice before The Bachelorette even began airing. In the email she said, “He [Justin] claims he’s doing it for the fame and he wants to get some wrestling career or something out of it, but how stupid will I look when I wait for him to go on this show, he comes back to me (if he doesn’t end up falling for her like he claims) and then the whole world watches MY bf hooking up another woman on national television?” Things sure got ugly when Ali confronted Justin and gave him the boot! Yikes!

ADVERTISEMENT

9. Bentley Williams

What a stand up single-dad…not! This piece of work wound up on Ashley Herbert’s season of The Bachelorette and quickly became known as a two-faced jerk! Williams admitted that Ashley wasn’t his type and bad-mouthed her in interviews while simultaneously acting charming and feigning feelings for her to her face. The show was heavily criticized for not informing Ashley of the rouse, but Harrison retorted to TVGuide.com, “Everyone says the producers are jerks and how could [we] do that to her, but she always has the decision, she can always get rid of this guy. You didn’t even see how much I begged her and bagged on this guy on Night 1. When she’s telling me the story, I’m like, ‘His name’s Bentley. Right there, run!'” 

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT